APPEALS - 2007
| Case Nos. | Applicant Name | Respondent Name | Remarks |
| Apl 43/2006/TCP | SS Naik | Sr Town Planner, Margao | Appeal allowed |
| Apl 45/2006/PWD | Mishel D`Sa | PWD | Appeal dismissed |
| Apl 49/2006/CCP | ML Ahuja | CCP | Appeal is allowed. SCN Issued to Commissioner, CCP |
| Apl41/06/Excise | Gopi Tirodkar | PIO Excise Dept | Appeal is allowed, Documents to be supplied; Asst Commissioner, Excise penalised Rs 5000 |
| Appl 52-2006-Police | Agostinho Proenca | S.P. (North) | SCN has been issued on PIO for penalty. |
| Appl 51-2006-Commu | Lt. Col. Sylvester M. D`Souza | Administrator of Commu., North Goa, Mapusa. | PIO is directed to remain present with all the documents regarding the Communidade of Sangolda. |
| Appl 57-2006-Elect | Santosh M. Gaonkar | Superintending Engineer, Electricity Dept., Panaji. | Appeal is dismissed. |
| Appl 66-2006-Goa-Uni. | Dr. G. C. Pradhan & S. K. Pradhan | Goa University. | Appeal is dismissed. |
| Appl 41-2006-GCZMA | Ligorio Pereira | Goa Coastal Zone Management Authority, Saligao. | M.S., GCZMA directed to produce original file of approval letter and site plan. |
| Appl 65-2006-VP | Gregory Noronha | VP Secretary Marna Siolim. | Appeal is rejected. |
| Appl 63-2006-DTE | John Philip Pereira | Directorate of Technical Education, Porvorim. | Appeal is rejected as barred by law of limitation. |
| Appl 60-2006-VP | I. Samuel Raju | VP Secretary Canca Benaulim. | PIO is directed to furnish the information within one week. |
| Appl 61-2006-VP | I. Samuel Raju | VP Secretary Canca Benaulim. | Appeal is dismissed. |
| Appl 62-2006-VP | I. Samuel Raju | VP Secretary Orlim, Salcete. | PIO is directed to furnish the information within one month. |
| Appl 52-2006-Police-P | Agostinho Proenca | S.P. (North), Porvorim. | Penalty proceedings dropped against PIO. |
| Appl 85/2006/W&CD | | | Appeal allowed. |
| Appl No. 91/2006/MAM | Suresh D. Naik | Mamlatdar of Pernem taluka. | Appeal is rejected. |
| Apl. No.71/2006/Police | Sushant Nagvenkar | S.P. Headquarters, Panaji. | Appeal is rejected. |
| Appl. No. 43/2006/TCP-P | Sushant Naik | Town & Country Planning Dept., Quepem. | Penalty proceedings dropped against the PIO. |
| Appl No. 76/2006/PWD | Sushant Naik | Suptdg. Surveyor of Works, PWD, Panaji. | PIO is directed to furnish the information and SCN has been issued against the PIO. |
| Appl No. 93/2006/MAM | Suresh Naik | Mamlatdar of Pernem Taluka | PIO is directed to furnish the information within 15 days. |
| Appl No. 92/2006/MAM | Suresh Naik | Mamlatdar of Pernem Taluka. | PIO is directed to furnish the information within 10 days. |
| Appl 73/2006/Comm. | Shri Alexinho F. Monserrate | Adminstrator of Communidades, Central Zone, Panaji. | Appeal is allowed. |
| Appl 83/2006/WRD | V. U. P. Gaitonde | Water Resources Department. | Appeal is allowed. |
| Appl 67/2006/POL | Joao C. Pereira | Supdt. of Police (South) | Appeal is rejected. |
| Appl 95/2006/POL | Joao C. Pereira | Supdt. of Police (South), Margao. | PIO is directed to provide the access to the information and inspection of case diary recordings. |
| Appl 94/2006/POL | Joao C. Pereira | Supdt. of Police, (South), Margao. | Appeal is rejected. |
| Appl 101/2006/Police | Shri Luel Fernandes | Supdt. of Police (North), Porvorim. | Appeal is partly allowed. |
| Appl 88/2006/GCA | Roy C. D`Souza | Goa College of Architecture, Panaji. | Appeal is partly allowed. |
| Appl 89/2006/Elect. | John Nazareth | Electricity Department, Panaji. | SCN has been issued against the PIO. |
| Appl 01/2007-08/VP | I. Samuel Raju | VP Secretary Canca-Benaulim, Salcete. | Appeal is diposed. |
| Appl 05/2007-08/Elect. | Shri C. Vales | Electricity Department. | Appeal is dismissed. |
| Appl 98/2006/FES | Shri Prakash M. Parab | Fire & Emergency Services, Panaji. | SCN has been issued against the PIO for penalty. |
| Appl 06/2007-08/Addl.Col | Pravin H. Zantye | Collector of North Goa. | FAA is directed to afford an opportunity to the Appellant and decide the matter on merits within 30 days from the date of the receipt of the order. |
| Appl 99/2006/Addl.Col. | Amar B. Naik | Additional Collector - I (South), Margao. | PIO is directed to provide the information and compensation of Rs.1000/- to the Appellant. |
| Appl 79/2006/TCP | M. K. Madhu | Town & Country Planing Dept., Panaji. | SCN has been issued against the PIO for penalty and also disciplinary proceedings. |
| Appl 96/2006/SDCT | Manohar Parwar | State Director of Craftsmen Training, Panaji. | Appeal is dismissed. |
| Appl 04/2007-08/CLE | Kum. Sushama G. Aldonkar | Commissioner of Labour & Employment, Panaji. | Appeal is dismissed. |
| Appl 102/2006/VP | John Nazareth | V.P. Secretary Merces. | PIO is directed to give complete information. Appeal is partly allowed. |
| Apl58/06/PWD | Santosh Dicholkar | PWD | Appl allowed, Info to be supplied within 2 weeks |
| Apl 53/06/ TCP | I Samuel Raju | PIO, TCP Margao | Appl dismissed |
| Appl 69/2006/VP | Nazaziano Paes | Secretary, V.P. Assolna. | Appeal is partly allowed. |
| Appl 14/2007/Dy. Col | Pandu Shetgaonkar | Dy. Collector & SDO, Mapusa. | SCN has been issued against Dy. Collector & SDO, Mapusa why penalty proceedings should not be initiated against him. |
| Appl 21/2007-08/GU | Dr. G. C. Pradhan | Goa University. | Appeal is allowed. PIO is directed to give requested information within 15 days. |
| Appl 15/2007-08/VP | Shri Pascoal Sequeira | V. P. Secretary - Aldona, Bardez. | PIO is directed to give reply to the first query of the Appellant within 10 days. |
| Appl 32/2007-08/MMC | Lenny Francis Barros | Margao Municipal Council, Margao. | Appeal is dismissed as withdrawn. |
| Appl 39/2007/VP | Balchandra R. Naik | V. P. Secretary, Bhoma-Adcolna, Ponda. | Appeal is dismissed. |
| Appl 36/2007/SXC | Mr. Thomas Alvares & others | St. Xavier`s College, Mapusa. | Appeal is rejected. |
| Appl 42/2007/Mam | Lausa Pereira e Dias | Mamlatdar of Salcete Taluka, Margao. | Respondent No. 2 is directed to remain present alongwith certified copies in the Commission. |
| Appl 19/2007-08/IPHB | Jude L. Vaz | Medical Supdt., IPHB, Bambolim. | Appeal is dismissed. |
| Appl 22/2007-08/VP | Digamber Naik | V.P. Secretary Madkai, Madkai - Goa. | Penalty of Rs.1000/- on V.P. Secretary Madkai. |
| Appl 24/2007-08/Police | Joao C. Pereira | Supdt. of Police (South), Margao. | Appeal is dismissed. |
| Appl 29/2007-08/EDN | Cajetan Pereira | Directorate of Education, Panaji. | Appeal is partly allowed. |
| Appl 31/2007-08/PH | Dr. Lanfredo Da Costa | Directorate of Health Services, Panaji. | Joint Secretary (Health), Secretariat is directed to physically verify the records available with the Medical Supdt. of Hospicio Hospital, Margao. |
| Appl 25/2007-08/AHVS | Shrikant Joshi | Directorate of Animal Husbandry & Veterinary Services, Panaji. | Appeal is partly allowed. |
| Appl 33/2007-08/DIT | Joao J. Caldeira | Information Technology, Panaji. | Appeal is allowed. |
| Appl 42/2007-08/Mam | Lausa Pereira e Dias | Mamlatdar of Salcete, Margao. | Appeal is allowed. |
| Appl 57/2007-08/CPD | Allan Falleiro | Captain of Ports Department, Panaji. | Appeal is partly allowed. |
| Appl 77/2007-08/GU | Ketan S. Govekar | Goa University, Taleigao Plateau - Goa. | Appeal is dismissed as withdrawn. |
| Appl 84/2006/US(H) | Dr. M. N. Pal | Under Secretary (Health). | Appeal is partly allowed. |
| Appl 72/2006/PWD | Joao J. Caldeira | PWD. | Appeal is allowed and compensation of Rs.5000/-. |
| Appl 100/2006/Dy.Col. | Shri C. S. Barreto | Dy. Collector & SDO, Bardez. | Appeal is allowed and PIO is directed to give specific reply to the Appellant. |
| Appl 75/2006/Elect. | Cosmas Jose Pinto | Electricity Dept. | Appeal is rejected. |
| Appeal No. 03/2007-08 | Surekha Bute | Forest Department, Panaji. | Appeal is partly allowed. SCN has been issued against Range Forest Officer, Panaji why penalty of Rs.250/- should not be imposed on him. |
| Appl 46/2007-08/SBHS | Engr. Rabindra A. L. Dias | St. Britto`s High School, Mapusa. | Appeal is dismissed. |
| Appl 43/2007-08/DPS | John Philip Pereira | Govt. Printing Press, Panaji. | Appeal is rejected. |
| Appl 59/2007-08/TCP | Rajiv Naik | Town & Country Planning Department, Panaji. | Appeal is partly allowed. |
| Appl 54/2007-08/VP | John Carmo Rodrigues | V.P. Secretary Chinchinim - Deussua, Salcete. | Complaint is allowed. |
| Appl 58/2007-08/Dy. Col. | Joao C. Pereira | Dy. Collector & SDO, Panaji. | Appeal is dismissed. |
| Appl 34/2007-08/Police | Joao C. Pereira | S.P. (South), Margao. | Appeal is partly allowed. |
| Appl 45/2007-08/MMC | Margao Municipal Council | Santosh M. Raiker | Appeal is dismissed as not maintainable. |
| Appl 66/2007-08/CMC | Alex Fernandes | Curchorem-Cacora Municipal Council, Curchorem. | Appeal is partly allowed. |
| Appl 62/2007-08/GAPL | P. V. Desai | Goa Antibiotics & Pharmaceuticals Ltd., Tuem. | Appeal is dismissed. |
| Appl 52/2007-08/US(GA) | Joao C. Pereira | Under Secretary (GA), Secretariat, Porvorim. | Appeal is dismissed having no merit. |
| Appl 50/2007-08/VP | Rabindra A. L. Dias | V.P. Secretary Sernabatim, Vanelim, Colva & Gandaulim, Salcete. | Respondent No. 1 is directed to produce original documents on 13/12/2007. |
| Appl 60/2007-08/SWB | Sushant Nagvenkar | Department of Sainik & Welfare Board, Panaji. | Appeal is partly allowed. |
| Appl 69/2007-08/JS | Dr. U. A. Vinay Kumar | Jt. Secretary to Governor, Cabo Raj Bhawan, Dona Paula. | Appeal is partly allowed. |
| Appl 72/2007-08/Edu. | Premanand Phadte | Directorate of Education, Panaji. | Appeal is allowed. |
| Appl 73/2007-08/Edu. | Premanand Phadte | Directorate of Education, Panaji. | Appeal is partly allowed. |
| Appl 51/2007-08/US(PER) | Gajanan Phadte | Under Secretary (Personnel - II), Secretariat, Porvorim. | Notice has been issued to Dr. M. Modassir to file his reply. |
| Appl 70/2007-08/GEC | Engr. Rabindra A. L. Dias | Goa Engineering College, Farmagudi, Ponda. | Appeal is dismissed. |
| Appl 44/2007-08/Police | Shri. Rabindra A.L. Dias | S.P. (South), Margao. | Appeal is partly allowed. |
| Appl 79/2007-08/Mam. | John Eric Gomes | Mamlatdar of Bardez Taluka, Mapusa. | Appeal is dismissed. |
| Appl 77/2006/DM | Sushant S. Naik | Directorate of Mines, Panaji. | Appeal is dismissed. |
| Appl 53/2007-08/MAM | Rodolfo Castro | Mamlatdar of Bardez Taluka, Mapusa. | Appeal is dismissed as withdrawn. |
| Appl 55/2007-08/GU | Gajanan Haldankar | Goa University, Taleigao Plateau, Goa. | Respondents are directed to produce the marks register before the Commission. |
| Appl 78/2007-08 | Allan Falleiro | Goa - IDC, Panaji. | Appeal is allowed. |
| Appl 81/2007-08/Excise | Sunil S. Shetye | Asst. Commissioner of Excise, Panaji. | Appeal is dismissed. |
| Appl 48/2007-08/GMC | Deepak B. Naik | Medical Suptd., Goa Medical College, Bambolim. | SCN has been issued against Director (Admn.) of GMC. |
| Appl 63/2007-08 | Sandesh N. S. Kosssambe | Sanguem Municipal Council, Sanguem - Goa. | SCN has been issued against Chairperson, Sanguem Municipal Council, Sanguem. |
| Appl 61/2007-08/VP | Nazaziano Paes | V. P. Secretary Assolna, Salcete - Goa. | Appeal is dismissed. |
| Appl 71/2007-08/Elect. | Rabindra A. L. Dias | Superintending Engineer, Circle - I (South), Electricity Dept., Margao. | Electricity Dept. is directed that proper rules be framed within two months prescribing the time for destruction of records. |
| Appl 84/2007-08/Elect. | Dy. Inspector General A. K. Dey | Superintending Engineer, Circle - I, Electricity Dept., Margao. | Appeal is partly allowed. |
| Apl 49A/2006/TCP | ML Ahuja | TCP | Appeal partly allowed |
| Apl 48P/06/IDC | Uday M Rege | PIO IDC | Penalty Proceedings dropped |
| Apl 54/06/Tcp | Samuel Raju | PIO, TCP | Appeal dismissed |
| Appl 59-2006-Police | Shri Samiro Pereira | S.P. (South), Margao. | SCN has been issued and compensation of Rs.2000/-. |
| Appl 49-P-2006-CCP | M. L. Ahuja | Commissioner of CCP, Panaji. | Penalty proceedings dropped against the PIO. |
| Appl 12/2007-08/EDC | Ms. Audrey J. Colaco | Goa Educational Development Corporation, Panaji. | Appeal is dismissed. |
| Appl 07/2007-08/VP | Hilario Sequeira | Village Panchayat Goltim-Navelim. | SCN has been issued against VP Secretary why penalty of Rs.250/- per day should not be imposed on him. |
| Appl 16/2007-08/Police | Adv. S. S. Saudagar | S.P. (South), Margao. | Appeal is partly allowed. |
| Appl 38/2007-08/MMC | Santosh M. Raiker | Margao Municipal Council, Margao. | Appeal is dismissed as withdrawn. |
| Appl 11/2007-08/Co-op. | Bismark Facho | Co-operative Societies. | PIO is directed to give information withheld by the Society on the Questions 4 and 5 to the Appellant within 15 days. |
| Appl 27/2007-08/PAN | Lt. Col. (Retd.) Paul B. Fernandes | Dy. Director of Panchayats (South), Margao. | Appeal is allowed. |
| Appl 37/2007-08/Co-op. | A. V. Shinde & C. K. Dessai | Co-operative Hsg. Society Ltd. | Appeal is dismissed for want of jurisdiction. |
| Appl 18/2007-08/NGPDA | V. A. Kamat | Member Secretary, North Goa PDA, Panaji. | Appeal is dismissed. |
| Appl No.80/2006/TCP | I. Samuel Raju | Town & Country Planning Dept., Margao. | Appeal is rejected. |
| Appl No. 81/2006/TCP | I. Samuel Raju | Town & Country Planning Dept., Margao. | PIO is directed to furnish specific information to the Appellant. |
| Appl No. 90/2006/TCP | Goa Environment Action Group | Town & Country Planning Dept., Mapusa. | Appeal is rejected as not maintainable. |
| Appl No. 78/2006/NGPDA | Ms. Patricia Pinto, General Secretary | North Goa PDA, Panaji. | PIO is directed to furnish the information. |
| Appl 97/2006/DM | Sushant S. Naik | Directorate of Mines, Panaji. | Appeal is allowed. |
| Appl 09-2007-VP | Francis Rodrigues | VP Navelim, Salcete. | Appeal is partly allowed with direction to supply the information. |
| Appl 64/2007-08 | Seby D`Silva | Shree Damodar College of Commerce & Economics, Margao. | Appeal is partly allowed. |
| Appl 67/2007-08/Police | Joao C. Pereira | S.P. (HQ), Panaji. | Appeal is dismissed. |
| Appl 83/2007-08/Mam. | Navin S. Parab | Mamlatdar of Pernem Taluka, Pernem. | Appeal is partly allowed. |
| Appl 86/2006/DAVHS | Dr. Rozario Menezes | Directorate of Animal Husbandry and Veterinary Services, Panaji. | PIO is directed to furnish the information. |
| Appl 82/2006/SGPDA | Shri Lenny Francis Barros | TCP & SGPDA. | PIO is directed to furnish the information to the Appellant. |
| Appl 47/2007-08/Sports | Rabindra A. L. Dias | Directorate of Sports & Youth Affairs, Panaji. | Appeal is dismissed. |
| Appl 02/2007-08/TCP | Pai Raiturker Shriram S. | Town & Country Planning Department, Margao. | Appeal is rejected. |
| Appl 13/2007-08/Dy.Col | Sushant S. Naik | Collector of South Goa, Margao. | Appeal is disposed off. |
| Appl 10/2007ADT | Jayanti G. Naik | Directorate of Transport, Panaji. | Appeal is dismissed. |
| Appl 17/2007-08/IDC | Sudan R. Desai | Goa IDC, Panaji. | Appeal is partly allowed. SCN has been issued against Range Forest Officer, Panaji why penalty of Rs.250/- should not be imposed on him. |
| Appl 23/2007-08/TCP | Santosh Raiker | South Goa PDA & Town & Country Planning Dept. | Appeal is dismissed. |
| Appl 26/2007-08/VP | Orlando Sales | Directorate of Foods & Drugs Administration, Panaji. | Appeal is dismissed. |
| Appl 20/2007/PER | Viyen Azavedo | Personnel Department, Secretariat, Porvorim. | Respondent No. 1 is directed to trace the relevant file and provide the information to the Appellant. |
| Appl 20/2007/DOT | Joao Caldeira | Department of Tourism, Panaji. | Appeal is partly allowed. |
| Appl 35/2007-08/Addl.Col. | C. S. Barreto | Additional Collector, North Goa District, Panaji. | Appeal is dismissed as withdrawn. |
| Appl 37/2007-08/Co-op. | A. V. Shinde & C. K. Desai | Shyam Metri & Ashok Naik, Goa Co-op. Hosg. Society, Taleigao. | Noticed to be issued to the Registrar of Co-operative Societies. |
| Appl 40/2007-08/NGZP | C. S. Barreto | North Goa Zilla Panchayat, Panaji. | Appeal is allowed. |
| Appl 41/2007-08/Info | Goa Heritage Action Group | Info Tech Corporation of Goa Ltd., Porvorim. | Appeal is dismissed as not maintainable. |
| Appl 74/2007-08/DTE | Premanand G. Phadte | Directorate of Technical Education, Porvorim. | Appeal is partly allowed. |
| Appl 49 & 76/2007-08/CCP | Rosendo dos Remedios Furtado & PIO | Corporation of the City of Panaji, Panaji. | Appl 49-07 is partly allowed and Appl 76-07 is dismissed. |