APPEALS - 2006
| Case Nos. | Applicant Name | Respondent Name | Remarks |
| Appeal13=Police | Jc Periera | Dy.S.P and others | Ratio:DG Police directed to issue instructions to APIOs ;Apellate Authority to pass speaking orders after hearing appellant |
| Appeal14-2006-Mam | CS Barreto | Mamlatdar, margao | Ratio:Non-payment of application fee is remedial defect;Merely because compilation of requested info is difficult, info cannot be denied. |
| Apl23_06_Mines | SS Naik | PIO of MINES | Only docs listed u/s 7(5) have to be given free of charge if PIO does not issue within one month. Info cannot be denied if citizen does not meet PIO. |
| Appl11&16_2006_Police | Pranay Kamat | PIO Police | APIO cannot refuse information |
| Appeal 24-06-DOT | Usgao | as Seva Society Vs DOT | Commission does not have jurisdiction to compell public authority to do its legal duties under the Acts other than RTI Act |
| Apl8-2006-Police | Anumawa Natekar | SP South | Information is given and appeal is dismissed |
| Apl15-2006-PWD | Alexinho Monserrate | Ex. Engineer Div II, Panaji | Section 6 (3), (6),: 7 (1) : 19(6) explained. Held that the respondents deliberately denied information notice for penalty issued |
| Apl 20-2006-DCF(N) | Shrihari Kugaji | DCF (N) | Appeal is dismissed as the information is already provided. |
| Apl 9 & 10-M-2006-Police | Joao Pereira | S.P. (South) | Complaint is dismissed. |
| Apl 13-M-2006-Police | Joao Pereira | S.P. Headquarters. | Complaint is dismissed. |
| Appeal 31-2006-MMC | Guiri S. Pai Raikar | Margao Municipal Council | Appeal is dismissed. |
| Appeal 32-2006-PAN | C. S. Barreto | V.P.Anjuna | SCN has been issued to the PIO regarding penalty. |
| Appeal 34-2006-PAN | C. S. Barreto | V. P. Assagao. | Appeal is rejected as information is provided. |
| Appeal 15-2006-PWD-P | Alexinho Monserrate | Public Works Department | Proceedings are dropped against PIO as PIO was not involved in the present case E.E. has dealth with matter. |
| Appl7-2006-Sect | | | PIO Vs Mr.VB Prabhu Verlekar: Ratio: The SPIO has no right of appeal against the I Appellate Authority as he is not an aggreived party under RTI Act |
| Apl18 & 19-2006-Police | Joao Pereira | SP South | Scope of Section 8 (1) (g) & (h) of RTI Act & Section 125 of Evidence Act examined. |
| Appeal 27-2006-Police | Joao Pereira | Police Dept. (south), Margao. | SCN has been issued to the PIO. |
| Appeal 40-2006-PER | Dr. M. N. Pal | U. S. (Personnel) | Appeal is rejected. |
| Appeal 33-2006-MAM | Amar Naik | Mamlatdar of Sanguem | Appeal is dismissed as time barred. |
| Appeal 35-2006-Sports | Savita P. Velip | Direcotrate of Sports, Panaji. | SCN has been issued to the PIO regarding penalty. |
| Appeal 36-2006-ELECT | J. T. Shetye | Electricity Dept., Sub Div. I(U), Mapusa. | PIO is directed to furnish the information within 15 days. |
| Appeal 27-2006-Police-P | Joao C. Pereira | Supdt. of Police (South) | As the Commission has satisfied with the explanation given by the PIO to the SCN, proceedings are dropped. |
| Appeal 25-2006-Goa-IDC | S. K. Agnihotri | Goa Industrial Development Corporation. | PIO is directed to furnish the correct information. |
| Appl 55-2006-Edu. | Premanand G. Phadte | Directorate of Education, Panaji. | Appeal is closed as withdrawn. |
| Appeal 3/2006/DFS | | | |
| Appl/12/2006 | | | Dr E. Rodrigues Vs Director Education---Dismissed as withdrawn |
| Apl17-2006-Police | Kapil L Sheth | SP CID | Police directed to give information except on one point where third party has to be given opportunity of hearing before deciding the matter |
| Appeal 9 & 10-2006-Police | Joao C. Pereira | SP (South) | Appeal is allowed. Police department to pay compensation of Rs.1000/-. |
| Appeal 42-2006-CCP | Shital S. P. Nachinolkar | Corporation of City of Panaji | Appeal is dismissed as withdrawn. |
| Appeal 38-2006-PAN | Cosme Romaldo Silveira | Dy. Director of Panchayats, Margao. | Appeal is dismissed. |
| Appeal 41-2006-GCZMA | Ligirio Pereira | Goa Coastal Zone Management Authority, Saligao. | Interim Order has been issued to the then Secretary of Goa Coastal Zone Management Authority, Dr. Varde. |
| Appeal 48-2006-Goa-IDC | Uday M. Rege | Goa Industrial Development Corporation | SCN has been issued to the PIO regarding penalty. |
| Appeal21-2006-CCF | Shrihari Kugaji | Chief Conservator of Forest, Panaji | Chief Conservator of Forest is directed to furnish the information |
| Apl 22-2006-DCF(S) | Shrihari Kugaji | DCF (S) | Appeal is dismissed as the information is already provided. |
| Apl 29-2006-ZP(S) | Sushant Naik | Zilla Panchayat (S) | Appeal is dismissed as the information is already provided. |
| Appeal 28-2006-PAN | C. S. Barreto | Director of Panchayat | Appeal is dismissed. |
| Appeal 30-2006-DTE | John Philip Pereira | Director of Technical Education | Appeal is partly allowed. The Respondent is directed to furnish the information. |
| Appeal 37-2006-PAN | Jhon P. Pereira | V.P. Secretary, Nagoa, Salcete. | Appeal is dismissed as information is provided. |